Pages

Thursday, February 16, 2006

Cheering the Defeat of Critical Analysis

Bill Dembski notes that Darwinist bloggers are ecstatic that the Ohio State Board of Education has removed "critical analysis of evolution" from its standards and wonders whether:

[T]here is any other field of inquiry - other than evolution, that is - whose advocates become ecstatic when critical analysis of its subject is suppressed. Usually, advocates of a position are happy to entertain critical analysis because such criticism highlights the importance of their subject and facilitates its further development. Of course, there's a qualifier that needs to be added to this question: Are there any legitimate fields of inquiry that discourage critical analysis of their subject areas?

Good questions. The reaction of the anti-ID crowd to this step by the Ohio Board looks less like the response of dispassionate objective scientists and very much more like the reaction of religious enthusiasts.