Saturday, October 12, 2024

Paying Their Fair Share

Politicians are fond of telling us that the rich must pay their "fair share" of taxes, but "fair share" is almost never defined. What is the fair share of the very rich? Should they pay all of the taxes required to feed our voracious federal government? What percentage of the total tax burden would be fair?

Parts of the following are excerpted from an article by William McBride, Vice President of Federal Tax Policy. It may surprise you to know that according to the latest IRS data for 2020 the top 1 percent of taxpayers (about 1.6 million filers who earn more than $548,336) paid $723 billion in income taxes, or 42.3 percent of all income taxes paid—a larger share than the bottom 95 percent of taxpayers combined.

The top 5 percent of taxpayers (about 7.9 million filers that earn more than $220,521) paid in aggregate $1.1 trillion in income taxes, amounting to 62.7 percent of all income taxes paid that year.

I couldn't find more recent data but economists think the tax paid by the highest earners is even greater since 2020. According to White:
High income taxpayers also pay the highest tax rates, according to the IRS. The average income tax rate in 2020 was 13.6 percent.

The top 5 percent of taxpayers paid a 22.4 percent average rate while the top 1 percent of taxpayers paid a 26.0 percent average rate—more than eight times higher than the 3.1 percent average rate paid by the bottom half of taxpayers.

The top 0.001 percent, or the richest 1,575 tax returns filed in 2020, paid nearly $71 billion in income taxes and had an average tax rate of 23.7 percent.
The next time you hear a politician demand that the rich "pay their fair share" ask yourself why they don't tell us what they think a fair share would be. Maybe the answer is because they know that the rich are already paying a very hefty share of the taxes collected by the federal government every year and that they're just demagoguing the issue.