Biden's Shameful Betrayal

Noah Rothman at National Review wrote recently about the testimony given this week by Gold Star families of servicemen and women killed in the disgraceful rush to exit Kabul, in Afghanistan in August of 2021.

The seven bereaved family members spoke at an event convened by GOP Rep. Darrell Issa and testified about both their grief and Washington’s negligent conduct during and in the wake of the evacuation. Rothman writes:

[Their witness was] profoundly poignant. Their testimony has far-reaching implications, too, because the more we learn about the events that culminated in the attack on Hamid Karzai International Airport’s Abbey Gate, the more it looks like the Biden administration has whitewashed one of the deadliest days for American troops in their 20 years on the ground in Central Asia.

Recall what happened on August 26th, 2021. Learning that the Americans were precipitously pulling out of the country, terrified Afghans descended upon Karzai airport in a panicked attempt to get aboard one of the departing planes. The scene was chaotic:

At the time, President Joe Biden assured nervous observers of the disorder that the Taliban, which had recaptured Kabul just eleven days earlier, would provide security for the evacuees. Those guarantees proved insufficient to prevent one of the worst-case scenarios.

At 5:50 p.m. local time, a suicide bomber waded through the crowd at Abbey Gate and detonated an explosive belt, killing 13 American soldiers and wounding 45 more U.S. personnel. At least another 170 Afghan civilians also died in the attack.

Our government, in another of its steps toward destroying whatever credibility it has with the American people who pay their salaries, claimed that the attack was inevitable and unpreventable:

The Biden administration has affirmed in a variety of retrospective reports on the incident that it was little more than an unavoidable tragedy. An “After Action Review” released by the State Department in June conceded, “The airport gates were filled with potential dangers due to large, uncontrolled crowds and constant threats from ISIS-K and the Taliban,” and rather unhelpfully added that the deadly terrorist event those conditions facilitated only “underscored how dangerous the situation was.”

The danger, of course, was a direct consequence of the Biden administration's decision to abandon Kabul to the Taliban.

This assessment does not improve on the Pentagon’s assertion in February 2022 that the attack at Abbey Gate was inevitable. “Based upon our investigation, at the tactical level this was not preventable,” Brigadier General Lance Curtis told reporters.

The Gold Star families who spoke at Issa’s event this week were having none of it:

“To say it’s time to move on and there’s nothing more to be said as to the planning and the execution of how our country wrapped up a two-decade war, is an insult to all of us,” said the mother of Marine corporal Hunter Lopez.

“When our leaders, including the Secretary of Defense and our commander in chief called this evacuation a success, as if there should be celebration, it is like a knife in the heart for our families and for the people who came back and for every service member that served over this 20-year war,” Marine sergeant Nicole Gee’s grieving mother-in-law told attendees.

“I want the answers,” Marine corporal Humberto Sanchez’s mother demanded. “I want the truth. I want to go to sleep knowing my son did not die in vain. I want to know that this failure will not happen again.”

Were the deaths of Americans inevitable? Could it have been prevented? Certainly if the military was allowed by the Biden administration to keep sufficient forces in Afghanistan and allowed to use Bagram airbase instead of the indefensible Karzai airport in Kabul the outcome would've been much different, but Biden was in a hurry to evacuate our personnel, no matter how unwise his means of doing so, and consequently ignored the advice of his military commanders.

The Pentagon’s exculpatory final report contradicts the assessments offered by Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin at the time of the attack at the gate. Fewer than 24 hours prior to that deadly bombing, Austin instructed Defense Department leaders to prepare for an imminent “mass casualty event.”

That heightened state of alert was justified by what Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark Milley said was “significant” intelligence indicating that Afghanistan’s ISIS affiliate had prepared to mount a “complex attack” on NATO forces and their Afghan allies.

“I don’t believe people get the incredible amount of risk on the ground,” Austin said at the time.

On March 8 of this year, House Foreign Affairs Committee chairman Michael McCaul led hearings into the events that culminated in the attack at Abbey Gate. Marine sergeant Tyler Vargas-Andrews testified at that hearing, and he told the committee that he believes the attack that took two of his limbs may not have been as unavoidable as the Pentagon claims.

“Countless Afghans were murdered by the Taliban 155 yards in front of our position,” Vargas-Andrews said of the conduct in which the Taliban was engaged just feet away from U.S. soldiers.

“We communicated the atrocities to our chain of command and intel assets, but nothing came of it.”

On August 22, 2021, Vargas-Andrews said he told his superiors that he observed enemy assets conducting a test run of an IED attack on the airport.

He said he later received intelligence relating to IED threats and a description of an aspiring suicide bomber and his associate — a description that precisely matched two figures whom Vargas-Andrews encountered hours before the fateful attack on August 26.

Vargas-Andrews was in a position to kill the men he was quite sure were suicide bombers, but his superiors would not allow it:

He requested permission to engage the targets. “The response,” he said, was that “leadership did not have the engagement authority for us. [They told us], ‘Do not engage.'” The suspect individuals soon disappeared in the crowd.

“To this day, we believe he was the suicide bomber,” Vargas-Andrews lamented. “Our expertise was disregarded. No one was held accountable for our safety.”

Vargas-Andrews’s allegations are serious, and they remain unaddressed by the Pentagon or the State Department. Vargas-Andrews and his fellow service personnel have every right to be frustrated with the Biden administration’s senior leadership, particularly given the flippancy with which they have regarded the notion that anything could have been done differently to prevent this disaster.

"Frustrated" seems a rather euphemistic adjective, especially as it applies to the Gold Star families. They should be irate at everyone in the chain of command who was responsible for this debacle, including the officer who refused Vargas-Andrews' request to take out the suspects, all the way up to the Commander in Chief.

Of course, the disaster that occurred on August 26, 2021, was preventable. As Army Command sergeant major Jacob Smith told House investigators, the soldiers and civilians who died at Abbey Gate would have survived that day if the Biden administration had not made the incomprehensible decision to reduce America’s footprint in Afghanistan down to a skeleton force such that it could no longer hold Bagram Airbase.

“The events that happened at Abbey Gate, I believe that would not have occurred at Bagram,” Smith said in June. “The defenses that Bagram held [with] the ability to see for hundreds of meters and the defense in depth of its control points — I do not believe the result would have been the same.”

That’s the long and short of it. Joe Biden’s stubborn insistence on maintaining as small an American presence as possible in Afghanistan ahead of the withdrawal date his White House negotiated with the Taliban created the conditions for a national humiliation culminating in the deaths of 13 U.S. soldiers.

It was a preventable debacle, and there has not yet been a full public accounting of on-the-record claims that the suicide bomber who killed scores of Americans and Afghans could have been neutralized.

“These deaths were preventable,” Sergeant Gee’s mother-in-law mourned. “My daughter could be with us today.” America deserves to know for certain if she is right.

But as long as our media sees itself as an extension of the Democrat Party no one will ever be held accountable for what happened that day. As it is, despite this enormous "national humiliation", no one has lost his or her job. That's a symptom of an administration that just doesn't really care about the lives lost in our unseemly retreat from Kabul, and the thousands of Afghans subsequently tortured and murdered by the Taliban for cooperating with the U.S.

Biden's disgraceful retreat deserves to go down in American history as one of the most shameful acts of treachery and betrayal ever committed by an American president.